Red Dead Redemption 2 Game Review: Still Worth It?

red dead redemption 2 game review

Is Red Dead Redemption 2 still worth buying? Yes, if you’ve got the patience for it. Rockstar’s western moves at the pace of a horse ride, and it tells one of the best stories in gaming. This Red Dead Redemption 2 game review covers what works, what annoys, and the practical questions everyone asks: release date, file size, and crossplay.

What Is Red Dead Redemption 2?

Red Dead Redemption 2 is an open-world western from Rockstar Games and a prequel to the original Red Dead Redemption. You play Arthur Morgan, a senior enforcer in the Van der Linde gang, as the crew runs from the law and from a country changing around them.

A quick note on names. Search “red dead” and you’ll land on the whole series, which began with Red Dead Revolver in 2004. This review covers only the second Redemption game. You don’t need the first one to follow the plot, though John Marston’s story hits harder if you’ve played it.

When Was the Red Dead Redemption 2 Release Date?

Red Dead Redemption 2 released on October 26, 2018, for PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. The PC version followed on November 5, 2019.

PlatformRelease date
PlayStation 4October 26, 2018
Xbox OneOctober 26, 2018
PCNovember 5, 2019

Rockstar went console-first, the same approach it took with Grand Theft Auto V. PC players waited over a year.

What Year Does Red Dead 2 Take Place?

Red Dead Redemption 2 takes place in 1899, about twelve years before the 1911 setting of the first game. That gap shapes everything. Trains, telegraphs, and Pinkerton agents are closing in, and the outlaw life is running out of road. The gang feels like it’s clinging to a world that’s already gone.

Story and Characters: Where the Game Wins

The story is why this game sits near the top of so many best-ever lists. Arthur starts as a loyal, hard-edged enforcer and slowly begins to doubt Dutch, the gang’s charismatic leader. Roger Clark’s voice work sells every crack in that loyalty.

The camp is the heart of it. Between missions you’ll overhear arguments, jokes, and quiet confessions while you do chores, and those small moments are what make the later chapters hurt. I won’t spoil anything. I’ll only say the six chapters build patiently and the ending lands.

One honest warning: the opening hours are slow. Chapter 1 is a snowy tutorial that plenty of players find tedious. Push through it.

Gameplay: Slow on Purpose

The gameplay is deliberate, and that’s both the charm and the complaint. Arthur moves with weight. Looting a body plays a full animation. Cooking, brushing your horse, and cleaning your guns are part of daily life. If you want a fast shooter, this isn’t it.

What you get instead is a world that reacts to you. Hunt a deer and you decide what to skin and carry. Bond with your horse and it stays calmer under fire. Gunfights lean on Dead Eye, a slow-motion targeting system that makes shootouts feel cinematic, though the controls can feel heavy, especially in crowded towns.

Missions mix heists, train robberies, and quiet side stories. The best ones blur the line between main and optional, so you rarely feel like you’re ticking boxes.

Graphics and World Design

The visuals still hold up. Light filters through the trees, storms roll across the plains, and snow keeps the marks of your boots. Critics were blown away at launch: Metacritic lists a score of 97 for the PS4 and Xbox One versions and 93 for PC.

The PC port looked the best of the bunch, but reviewers at the time noted a range of launch issues. Check current patch notes before you buy.

How Large Is RDR2? File Size by Platform

At launch, Rockstar listed Red Dead Redemption 2 at 99 GB on PS4 and 107 GB on Xbox One. The PC version needs roughly 150 GB.

PlatformInstall size at launch
PlayStation 499 GB (PS4 digital needs an extra 50 GB during install)
Xbox One107 GB
PCAbout 150 GB

Updates add to those numbers, so leave breathing room. If your PC has an SSD, install it there.

Is Red Dead Online Cross-Platform?

No. Red Dead Online doesn’t support crossplay between PlayStation, Xbox, and PC, and Rockstar has never added it. GTA Online works the same way. Players within the same console family can generally play together across generations, but your PC friends can’t join your console lobby.

Red Dead Online also gets far less support than GTA Online. It’s a fun side trip for fishing, bounty hunting, and riding with friends, but treat it as a bonus rather than the reason to buy.

Do You Need to Play the First Red Dead Redemption?

No. The 2010 original is set in 1911 and follows John Marston, who shows up here as a younger, rougher member of the gang. RDR2 explains how that crew fell apart, so playing it first spoils nothing about Arthur’s story. Playing it second is the better order for most people. You learn why the later game’s ending carries so much weight, and you meet familiar faces before they become legends.

What Works and What Doesn’t

The goodThe frustrating
A story with real emotional weightA slow opening chapter
A living camp full of small storiesHeavy, deliberate controls
Voice acting that sells every sceneA big install and big hardware needs
A world full of detail worth exploringRed Dead Online gets limited support

Who Should Play Red Dead Redemption 2?

  • Play it if you love story-driven games and want characters you’ll think about for weeks.
  • Play it if you enjoy world detail and like taking your time.
  • Skip it if you want constant action and fast pacing.
  • Skip it if slow animations and heavy controls drive you up the wall.

Our Red Dead Redemption 2 Game Review Verdict: 9.5 out of 10

Red Dead Redemption 2 earns a 9.5 out of 10. It’s slow and occasionally stubborn, but it gives you a world and a cast you’ll remember long after the credits. If you’ve been putting it off, start it this weekend.

Love story-first games? Read our Star Wars review next, or browse more trending game reviews here on The Article Authority.

Red Dead Redemption 2 FAQs

What is the Red Dead Redemption 2 release date?

Red Dead Redemption 2 released on October 26, 2018, for PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. The PC version arrived on November 5, 2019.

How large is RDR2?

At launch, RDR2 required 99 GB on PS4, 107 GB on Xbox One, and about 150 GB on PC. Updates increase these sizes over time.

Is Red Dead Online cross-platform?

No. Red Dead Online has no crossplay between PlayStation, Xbox, and PC. Players can only join others on their own platform family.

What year does Red Dead 2 take place?

The game takes place in 1899, roughly twelve years before the original Red Dead Redemption, which is set in 1911.

What is Red Dead?

Red Dead is Rockstar Games’ western series. It began with Red Dead Revolver in 2004 and includes Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2.